Mansions on the Market: Bay Island Gated Estate (PHOTOS)

Address: 3799 Flamingo Ave, Sarasota

Specs: 4 bedrooms | 4 bathrooms and 2 partial bathrooms | 8,138 square feet

List price: $21 million

Discover your very own gated, private peninsula on Siesta Key. 

Located on the north end of the island, this one-of-a-kind furnished estate sits on more than an acre, with over 700 waterfront feet. A custom-designed driveway leads to a grand entrance with waterfalls and fire features. 

Designed for entertaining, and a relaxed island lifestyle, this home features multiple living spaces, both inside and out, with an open-air lifestyle, walls of glass and rich wood and stone floor materials throughout. There is a game room, home theater, fitness room, meditation room and an 8-plus car garage. 

Complementing the interior, the outdoor space has an infinity edge pool, swim-up pool bar, a recessed seating area with fire pit in the pool, a dining pavilion, with a living plant wall, outdoor living room, with a fireplace, spa, outdoor kitchen and a koi pond running almost the entire length of the home, with built-in footbridges. 

For the water enthusiast, there is a boat dock and separate waterfront garage, as well as a paddleboard/canoe launch. 

Marketed by: Premier Sotheby’s International Realty; Joel Schemmel, 941-364-4000. 

You May Also Like
Mansions on the Market: Penthouse at TheRitz-Carlton Residences, Sarasota (RENDERINGS)

Live above it all in this full-floor penthouse, located atop the newest Ritz-Carlton-branded residential tower, in Sarasota. Nestled in the heart of The Quay, a waterfront district with shopping, dining

Read More
Listing alert: $10 million penthouse hits the market in downtown Tampa (RENDERINGS)

Hotel Ora + Private Residences, a $675 million luxury hotel-condominium tower rising near Water Street, has listed a $10 million, penthouse on the 39th level, complete with a personalized design

Read More
Mansions on the Market: Paradise Island Estate on Treasure Island (PHOTOS)

A contemporary luxury estate, built in 2022, is on the market in Treasure Island’s Paradise Island neighborhood, featuring water frontage totaling 127 feet. The three-story home spans 4,066 square feet

Read More
Lakefront estate with Oval Office replica hits market for $18.9 million in Thonotosassa (PHOTOS)

This 34,000-square-foot Mision Lago property offers history-inspired luxury minutes from Tampa

Read More
Other Posts
$2.6M deal completes full West Tampa block

A $2.6M sale completes a full block assembly at one of West Tampa’s key intersections.

Read More
McDill Columbus Plaza at 2700 N MacDill Avenue in West Tampa
The ReliaQuest Bowl’s $1.2B Impact on Tampa Bay

How a New Year’s Eve bowl game became a $1.2B economic engine for Tampa Bay.

Read More
Downtown Tampa skyline alongside the ReliaQuest Bowl logo highlighting the event’s economic impact on Tampa Bay
$34.7M Fair Oaks Recreation Center opens in East Tampa

East Tampa’s $34.7M Fair Oaks Recreation Center opens as a major community investment heading into 2026.

Read More
Aerial view of the Fair Oaks Recreation Center in East Tampa showing solar panels on the roof and surrounding neighborhood
St. Pete adds condo supply while Tampa stays tight

As St. Petersburg adds new condo inventory, Tampa’s market remains tight heading into 2026.

Read More
St. Petersburg skyline with downtown waterfront and marina