How Top-Performing CEOs Stand Out

The stereotypical CEO is characterized as a charming, tall, white man educated from a top university, a strategic visionary on a vertical career trajectory with the ability to make perfect decisions under pressure.

How many such people do you know? None, I bet.

Today’s business world is faster, smarter and, in many ways, younger than ever before.

You’re likely either in a tech-based startup or business—or you’re about to choose, or be forced—to transform your business to a “digital” model. Or, you’re already doing so. That takes real courage, conviction, investment and leadership.

What should that leadership look like?

A recent 10-year study—the CEO Genome Project, by Chicago-based leadership adviser ghSmart—busts a few myths. (Google it. It is rich with insight and information.) The firm used its proprietary database containing more than 17,000 assessments of C-suite executives, including 2,000 CEOs. The database has in-depth information on each leader’s career history, business results and behavioral patterns. It isn’t theory; the results are powerful.

Some surprising findings:

• Introverts are slightly more likely than extroverts to surpass the expectations of their boards/investors.

• Virtually all CEOs have made substantial mistakes, and almost half of them had at least one major career blowup.

• Academic degree didn’t correlate to performance. Less than 10 percent of the CEOs they evaluated had an undergraduate Ivy League education, and around 8 percent didn’t graduate from college at all.

• Confidence in interviews did not matter. High confidence more than doubles a candidate’s chances of being chosen as CEO but provides no advantage in performance on the job.

• Four specific behaviors prove critical to their performance. Research and experience suggest that when leaders aspire to move into the corner office and deliberately develop these behaviors, they dramatically raise the odds that they’ll become a high-performing chief executive.

In our next four articles, we will address each of these behaviors in depth. In the meantime, here’s some food for thought—the four behaviors:

1. Deciding with speed and conviction. No need for “all the data,” and comfortable with ambiguity.

2. Engaging for impact. High emotional intelligence—knowing what motivates various stakeholders, and how to works best with those motivations.

3. Adapting proactively. Stuff happens, and how you respond off-script matters most.

4. Delivering reliably. It’s all about results. Systems and processes matter.♦

Stephen Garber is director of Third Level Ltd. Contact him at 561.752.5505 or [email protected].

You May Also Like
It’s time for CEOs to rethink the role of human resources

By Christine Hairelson, vice president, employee experience at Accusoft/OnTask COVID was a massive stress test, and gut check, for every organization regardless of size, scope or industry. All departments were

Read More
Virtual Connect: The Radical CHRO Series Part 1 (FULL VIDEO)

Stop assuming, start listening. If you want to understand what’s really going on, try listening to your employees. Presented by KnowBe4 Panelists: Jennifer Currence, HR & Leadership Trainer Kelli Houdek,

Read More
Solving Skilled Labor Supply Chain Shortfalls

Hiring good people is hard. Hiring good people with specific skills, or credentials is harder. Hiring good people with specific skills, or credentials, in an industry where the demand is

Read More
Three things your company should do in response to landmark Supreme Court ruling on LGBTQ employees’ rights

Last week the Federal Supreme Court issued a landmark ruling affirming that Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 protects gay, lesbian and transgender employees from discrimination in

Read More
Other Posts
TD Charitable Foundation offers $7.2 million in grants to support homeownership sustainability

The TD Charitable Foundation, the philanthropic arm of TD Bank, has announced $7.2 million in grants to assist nonprofit organizations addressing challenges in sustaining homeownership for low- and moderate-income families.

Read More
Raymond James launches $7.5 million education initiative

Raymond James has announced Ready for School, a $7.5 million initiative to support Tampa Bay nonprofits that enhance educational opportunities for students. Over three years, the program will distribute $2.5

Read More
Strategically Planning Your Philanthropic Giving in 2025

Philanthropy is not simply about spontaneous generosity—it’s about creating lasting change. A change that reflects your personal values and makes a tangible difference. In 2024, our community demonstrated remarkable generosity,

Read More
Hurricane Recovery Rental Housing Fair to aid displaced residents

Residents displaced by Hurricanes Helene and Milton will have a chance to connect with housing providers at the Hurricane Recovery Rental Housing Fair, hosted by the City of St. Petersburg

Read More