Measuring Website Success Goes Beyond Search Engine Ranking

The quality of a website can make or break a business. When you invest in great design, strategic copy and a compelling user experience, you expect results – as you should. However, many business leaders are left wondering how to measure those results.

One critically important, and relatively easy to measure, metric is how you rank in search. As important as search engine ranking is, it’s far from the only indicator of a successful website. Your company needs to set goals for your website that are tied to your overall business goals. These are some of the ways a business can measure success.

7 Metrics for Measuring Website Success

  1. Traffic Sources

Undoubtedly, a strong SEO strategy should increase your search engine traffic. However, you should closely monitor traffic from other sources as well. Measure direct traffic, social media traffic and referral traffic. You might discover unexpected ways in which your site attracts qualified leads.

  1. Bounce Rate

No matter how many visitors find your site, you want them to take further steps toward conversion. Bounce rate shows you how many people leave after viewing only one page. As you adjust your website strategy to give visitors what they want, you should see that rate decrease.

  1. Click-Through Rates

Your website should lead a customer through the sales funnel, from awareness to purchase. You can follow along by looking at click-throughs. This analysis will give insight into the text, placement and usability of your CTAs. Make sure the experience is what was intended.

  1. Form Fills

You can, and should, measure all kinds of conversions but one particularly valuable type to watch is a form fill. When someone fills out a form, whether to request information, a consultation or a call back, they express a clear interest in your brand. A well designed form also captures information that teaches you more about your target audience and builds your email list.

  1. Gated Content Downloads

When a visitor is willing to trade their contact information for a valuable piece of content, they signal a strong interest in your brand and open the opportunity to market to them more proactively. Put a plan in place to nurture these leads through the funnel to a sale.

  1. Cart Abandonments

When a user puts a product in their shopping cart only to abandon it, treat this as a valuable learning opportunity. Your site metrics can provide clues as to why they left, while a remarketing campaign can allow you to re-engage them.

  1. Blog Interaction

Look at how people get to your blog, what they read and where they go next. Track whether learning something new on the blog translates to browsing your products or requesting more information. You might also set up your blog to allow comments or social sharing; these actions provide valuable data as well.

Your success metrics will vary from your competitor’s, just as your marketing strategy and tactics vary. And, you will adjust them over time. A great digital agency partner will help you to develop meaningful measurements, comparing them month-over-month and year-over-year. Together you will likely improve your search engine ranking for important keywords, but you should see positive change in other metrics as well. Above all, choose success metrics that are meaningful to you and your business goals. What you measure, you can improve.

Kevin Hourigan is the President and CEO of Bayshore Solutions and for over 23 years, his company has provided clients with digital solutions that grow their businesses. To contact Kevin, please email [email protected].

 

You May Also Like
Meet Dieumerci Christel, whose journey from a refugee camp is reshaping student-teacher connections

Born in a Tanzanian refugee camp, Dieumerci Christel is building Enlightapp to help schools strengthen connection and student engagement.

Read More
Dieumerci Christel sitting in a conference room wearing an NDSU sweatshirt while working on Enlightapp.
Iowa and Vanderbilt head to Tampa for ReliaQuest Bowl

Iowa and Vanderbilt will meet in Tampa on New Year’s Eve for a ReliaQuest Bowl matchup that brings national interest and strong economic impact.

Read More
ReliaQuest Bowl logo displayed over Raymond James Stadium with the phrase Football in Paradise.
Sheriff’s Indian Advisory Council hosts 2025 Annual Banquet at Bryan Glazer JCC

The Sheriff’s Indian Advisory Council celebrated community service and cultural unity at its 2025 Annual Banquet in Tampa.

Read More
Sheriff Chad Chronister stands with members of the Indian Advisory Council during the 2025 Annual Banquet.
St. Pete YMCA’s new CEO sets belonging as top priority

New CEO Nicci Bucher is leading the St. Pete YMCA with a focus on belonging, partnerships and community growth.

Read More
Nicci Bucher, newly appointed CEO of the YMCA of Greater St. Petersburg, stands outside a YMCA facility, smiling confidently. The YMCA logo is displayed beside her.
Other Posts
Tampa team leads high-risk extraction of Venezuelan opposition leader María Corina Machado

A Tampa rescue leader reflects on his highest-risk mission yet.

Read More
María Corina Machado appears publicly after her extraction while Bryan Stern, founder of Greybull Rescue, is shown in a portrait inset.
How Water Street hotels increased food and beverage revenue in 2025

A case study on how Tampa’s Water Street hotels used food and beverage to drive growth in a year when room revenue stalled.

Read More
Aerial view of the JW Marriott Tampa Water Street and Tampa Marriott Water Street overlooking the waterfront and marina in downtown Tampa.
D.C. based firm buys garden-style apartment complex east of downtown

A D.C. based firm has acquired Luxe at 1820, a 300 unit apartment community east of downtown as Tampa’s growth keeps attracting national buyers.

Read More
Exterior view of Luxe at 1820 apartment buildings in Brandon with palm trees in front, alongside inset images showing the community’s resort-style pool and a modern clubhouse interior.
An iconic Davis Islands building is being rebuilt for its next 100 years

The Mirasol is returning as a restored boutique hotel and waterfront residence that brings new life and new investment to Davis Islands.

Read More
Rendering of the restored Hotel Mirasol on Davis Islands at dusk, showing its Mediterranean Revival architecture with arched windows, palm trees, and guests at the entrance. An inset site plan highlights the redesigned waterfront layout, including new residences, hotel suites, pool area, gardens, and marina access.