Navigating the Current State of the Florida Property Insurance Market

The Florida property insurance market is in a state of flux with rising rates, non-renewals and companies leaving the state altogether. This is due to a number of factors including the state’s hurricane vulnerability, high litigation costs and a number of other challenges.

What’s causing the crisis?

Hurricanes: Florida is one of the most hurricane-prone states in the country and insurers have incurred billions of dollars in losses, in recent years, due to major storms such as Irma, Ian and now Idalia.

Litigation costs: Florida has a unique legal system that makes it easy for homeowners to sue their insurers. This has led to a surge in litigation, which has driven up costs for insurers.

Other challenges: The Florida property insurance market also faces a number of other challenges such as climate change, aging infrastructure and rising construction costs.

What does this mean for homeowners?

Homeowners in Florida are facing higher rates, non-renewals and fewer coverage options. In some cases, homeowners may be forced to purchase insurance from Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, the state-run insurer of last resort. Should this elevated storm cycle continue, the market will continue to limit homeowner’s choices.

What is the state doing to address the crisis?

The Florida legislature has passed a number of reforms in recent years, aimed at addressing the crisis in the property insurance market. However, more work is needed to make the market more affordable and stable for homeowners.

What does the future hold?

The future of the Florida property insurance market is uncertain. However, homeowners can take steps to protect themselves and their homes by shopping around for coverage, making improvements to their homes and having a plan in place in the event of a hurricane or other natural disaster.

What can homeowners do?

There are a number of things that homeowners can do to navigate the current state of the Florida property insurance market:

Raise your deductible: Raising your deductible can help to lower your premiums. However, it’s important to make sure that you can afford to pay your deductible if you need to file a claim.

Make improvements to your home: Making certain improvements to your home, such as installing hurricane shutters or a new roof, can also help you to qualify for lower rates.

Lindsey Kenney

Get involved: Homeowners can also get involved in advocating for reforms that would make the Florida property insurance market more affordable and stable.

Lindsey Kenney assumed the role of Private Client Account Executive at M.E. Wilson within our Personal Lines Department in September 2022. With an extensive career spanning over 14 years, Lindsey possesses a wealth of experience collaborating with our High-Net-Worth insurance partners. Lindsey’s specialized expertise lies in High-Net-Worth Personal Lines and account management. Her primary objective centers around creating long-lasting relationships with her clients while consistently providing exceptional value.

You May Also Like
Shumaker adds two new associates in Tampa office

Shumaker is expanding its Tampa office with the addition of two associates, a move that highlights both the depth of its national bench and the strength of Tampa Bay’s demand for legal talent. As the region continues to attract corporate relocations, mergers and investment activity, law firms are positioning themselves to meet client needs with

Read More
Headshots of Marisa A. Infante and Chase M. Robinson, newly added associates at Shumaker’s Tampa office.
A smarter approach to business insurance

For many business leaders, insurance has become one of those necessary line items—reviewed briefly at renewal time, signed off on and quickly forgotten. It’s transactional, seen as a balance sheet expense rather than the value driver it can be. In today’s business environment—defined by rapid change, emerging threats and shrinking margins for error—that traditional mindset

Read More
Shumaker launches two new legal service lines, names leaders in immigration and tech

Shumaker has expanded its legal offerings with the launch of two new service lines focused on immigration and technology, data privacy, cybersecurity and artificial intelligence. The firm, which has offices in the Tampa Bay area and is headquartered in Toledo, Ohio, also announced new leadership for these areas: Maria del Carmen Ramos, Partner – Immigration

Read More
Tampa’s Cassidy & Co. partners with Higginbotham for local life insurance planning

Higginbotham, an independent insurance, financial and human resources services firm, based in Fort Worth, Texas, has partnered with Tampa’s Cassidy & Company of Tampa, for specialty life insurance planning services in partner offices in Florida, Tennessee, Mississippi and more. Cassidy & Company serves high-net worth individuals, family offices, business owners and corporate clients create, protect

Read More
Other Posts
Future of Davis Islands’ Mirasol hinges on Jan. 15 vote

A Jan. 15 City Council vote will determine whether the historic Mirasol returns to its original use as a boutique hotel.

Read More
Historic Mirasol building on Davis Islands shown alongside archival photo as Tampa City Council vote approaches
How Dr. Irfan Ali built empathy into Tampa health care

A Tampa physician’s journey from trauma to leadership shows how empathy can reshape health care.

Read More
Dr. Irfan Ali in his Tampa office, reflecting on empathy, leadership and patient-centered health care
St. Pete Insurtech shows big profit on NYSE

Neptune CEO Trevor Burgess explains how AI, growth and a federal shutdown sparked his question: “Do we need the NFIP at all?”

Read More
Trevor Burgess and the Neptune Insurance team ringing the opening bell at the New York Stock Exchange on October 1, 2025.
Tampa attorney has built litigation practice on complex commercial cases

Melissa Murphy, a partner at Porter Wright, has a passion for helping people. From her days as a beach lifeguard to practicing law, that passion has stayed strong. However, over the last few years, Murphy’s passion has developed into litigating very large, complicated cases, often revolving around restrictive covenant and trade secret law. For her,

Read More