2021 Year In Review: My perfect dinner

When people find out I write restaurant articles, they always ask the same questions. The questions are, “What is your favorite restaurant” or “What is your favorite thing to order?” Recently, a friend asked me, “If you could create your perfect dinner, from your favorite dishes served by your favorite local restaurants, what would be on the menu?” After giving it some thought, here is my answer. My perfect dinner would start with the oysters at Donatello.

Oysters Rockefeller

Oysters Florentina at Donatello

This is the best version of the classic dish, Oysters Rockefeller, I’ve ever eaten. The best oysters, depending on the season, and availability, nestled into a bed of sauteed spinach and are presented on the half-shell. What makes these different, and special, is the sauce. It’s made with white wine, shallots and heavy cream. The cream is aerated a little, creating a lighter version than the classic Rockefeller, and allows the flavors of the spinach and oysters to be front and center. Oysters Florentina and bottle of Cristal Champagne is the perfect way to start a celebration dinner.

Wahoo Crudo

 Wahoo Crudo at Olivia

Ever since I wrote about this dish for Tampa Bay Business and Wealth’s March 2021 issue, I cannot stop thinking about it. It’s cool and delicious, with a mélange of flavors and a stunning presentation.  Brilliant colors of orange, vermillion and violet fill the plate, but don’t linger at the sight. The best part of this dish comes on the end of your fork. Mild wahoo is perfectly balanced by citrus, sweet soy, Calabrian aioli and sushi sauce. It’s garnished with edible flowers and is so light, and refreshing, it’s perfect for any time of day, any season of the year.

Ocean Roll

Sushi at Ocean Prime

A little sushi needs to be part of a perfect dinner and The Ocean Roll at Ocean Prime might just be my favorite. Grade 1-plus ahi tuna and avocado are wrapped in seaweed, then topped with thinly sliced yellowtail hamachi. Then, it’s topped with a crunchy chili-garlic oil. The crunchy oil really makes this dish.  It adds both flavor and texture that are subtle and forward at the same time. This makes a great starter to share with friends or a wonderful lunch, sitting at the bar with a glass of lush Chardonnay.

Short Rib Mezzluna

Pasta at Il Ritorno

Like most people, I love pasta and have eaten it almost everywhere. But the best pasta dish I’ve ever eaten, anywhere, is the short rib mezzaluna at Il Ritorno. Short rib-filled pillows of pasta, butter and white truffle oil are the foundation of upscale comfort food. Garlic and slow-roasted tomatoes add flavor and color. Everything is blanketed with Piave cheese and chives. The cheese strings from the tines of the fork, you mouth is coated with a rich blanket of butter and the pasta has the perfect bite. This dish proves there is a higher-being, looking down and wanting us to be happy.

Filet Mignon

Filet at The Black Pearl

A steak is a steak. When I want one, I buy the best quality meat I can find, and grill it at home on my Big Green Egg. I almost never order one out. But the Hereford filet, served at the Black Pearl, makes me re-think my steak-eating strategy. Chef Chris Artrip sears the beef in cast iron, for an even crust, then places it on mashed red potatoes, studded with a pomme gaufrette. A drizzle of chive oil is followed by a malbec-braised shallot glace de viande. It can be ordered with a butter-poached lobster tail or foie gras. The foie gras is scored and seared for an impressive presentation. The flavor of the liver is mild but distinct and feels lush on the tongue. The flavor of de viande takes this dish to the stratosphere. 

I still grill steak at home, but when I want something really special, I make a reservation at the Black Pearl.

Canoli

Cannoli at Casa Santo Stefano

The dessert that stole my heart last year was the cannoli at Casa Santo Stefano, and the shell is the reason why. The shell is made with a little Marsala wine, creating an extra-crisp, but delicate, shell that crumbles instead of breaking into big shards. The classic filling is studded with chocolate chips and stays on the right side of the sweetness line. This cannoli is unique and a shining star in a constellation of great desserts I enjoyed last year.

That’s my perfect dinner, based the restaurants I reviewed last year. Reading back over this article reminds me of other great dishes I’ve eaten at other local restaurants. My calendar is filled with reservations so I can relive my experiences. And that’s what I recommend for you. Support your local restaurants by dining out and trying new restaurants often. The Tampa Bay area is home to some great chefs, and restaurants, that are still struggling to recover from the COVID curse of the past two years.  Grab someone special and enjoy dinner out. 

You May Also Like
HEW Parlor & Chophouse brings glamour to Dunedin (PHOTOS)

Standing majestically along the waters of St. Joseph Sound, The Fenway Hotel is a captivating icon of Dunedin. Steeped in history, dating back to 1927, the hotel has been revitalized

Read More
The Revival of Don the Beachcomber (PHOTOS)

Although a tiki bar typically wouldn’t be included in a story on fine dining, the legendary Don the Beachcomber defies categorization. This isn’t your average kitschy cocktail haven. It’s a

Read More
The Revival of Don the Beachcomber
Michelin Guide adds Tampa restaurant to Bib Gourmand list

Michelin Guide inspectors added four Florida restaurants to its Bib Gourmand list as part of the 2024 Michelin Guide, including Streetlight Taco, in Tampa. Bib Gourmand restaurants are described as

Read More
Exploring the Culinary Legacy of the Rooster & the Till (PHOTOS)

The journey of Rooster & the Till began modestly, with its origins as a 37-seat restaurant nestled in the burgeoning neighborhood of Seminole Heights, a stone’s throw from downtown Tampa. 

Read More
Other Posts
Bern’s Winefest tickets go on sale March 2

Bern’s Steak House, in partnership with its sister properties Haven and the Epicurean Hotel, will hold its 27th Bern’s Winefest, presented by the Laxer Family Foundation, from April 13 to

Read More
Sneak peek of new Tampa Bay additions to the Michelin Guide in 2024

Michelin Guide inspectors have selected 19 new Florida restaurants to be added to the Michelin Guide Florida, in 2024, with six in Tampa. The restaurants include: Ebbe, 1202 N. Franklin

Read More
Fortu: The Wagyu stands alone (PHOTOS)

On the ground floor of the Ponce de Leon Hotel, in downtown St. Petersburg, is a cozy little restaurant space that previously was home to Ceviche Tapas Bar & Restaurant, for

Read More
Sonata: An orchestra of flavors at the Mahaffey (PHOTOS)  

In the vibrant tapestry of St. Petersburg’s culinary scene, a new symphony resonates at the Mahaffey Theater with the grand opening of Sonata Restaurant. Sonata is the combined vision of

Read More